Library Reviews Made Simple

Hi! Hope y’all are having a great week. Today was my last day of work at the Cowboys, so I will be more available for blogging and such. Anyway, I have a real treat today. Jenny Martin is a fabulous librarian who is a fellow member of the DFW Writers Workshop. I emailed her the other day to ask her how the School Library Journal reviews work. She responded with this great cheat sheet on the review process–and not just for SLJ. She said I could post her response, so here it is. Thanks, Jenny!

Library Reviews Made Simple

Different library journals have different review processes. School Library Journal uses volunteer reviewers. To become a reviewer, a librarian has to fill out an application with two sample reviews. The reviewers also follow policies, checklists, and guidelines. You can find these at: http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/info/CA6419413.html

Library Media Connection, another major review journal for School Librarians (one of my faves), also uses volunteer reviewers. Their policy is found here: http://www.linworth.com/pdf/lmc/write_or_review/lmcreviewerguidelines.pdf

ALA also provides a couple of great library review journals, Booklist and Book Links. Both journals have a dedicated review staff instead of volunteers. The nice advantage to this is that you can get a feel for the reviewers. These reviewers are more consistent and reliable about recommendations.

And at the top of the library review food chain is Horn Book. Horn book reviews are very influential. They have literary heavyweights reviewing titles. If a book is a *starred* Horn book, you better believe it will find its way onto library shelves.

In the majority of cases (definitely for SLJ) the publisher must provide one or more copies of the book at least two months before publication. The review process can take a couple months.

Any librarian worth his or her salt relies heavily on these journals. We call them “selection tools” for a reason. The majority of my school library purchases hinge on reviews from these journals. If an author’s book is reviewed well, it will sell to schools.

Another big factor is award lists. If a book is nominated on a state list (Bluebonnet, Lonestar, Tayshas, Maverick, etc.), many, many schools automatically buy it. For example, I buy two or three copies of all twenty Bluebonnet books every year. Of course, each state has their own, but the Texas lists are nationally known.

And…if you can get Junior Library Guild to pick up your book as a monthly selection, you’re in great shape.

Hope this info is helpful.

FAQ from Real Life

 

I get some funny questions from friends who are not familiar with the writing/publishing world. I certainly don’t blame them. I think it’s really difficult to understand anyone else’s industry unless you are a part of it. That’s why I’m always thankful that Nate and I were on the same sports team in college. Otherwise, I feel like I’d never have a clue what he was talking about. Same goes for writing. Although I think writers are probably a bit more sensitive toward “silly” questions.

I think there are several reasons for writers particular sensitivity. There is certainly a perceived feeling from the general public that writing is this weird, unrealistic dream that people just talk about. People tend to view it in the same light as someone saying “I’m moving to LA to become an actress AND a singer” without ever having taken an acting class or a singing lesson in her life. There are times when so-and-so finds out that you write, and so-and-so responds “oh yeah, my dad [insert relation here] wrote a book once.” And you have to smile and nod and say that’s great.

I don’t think that outsiders realize that there is an actual industry going on in the book world. There are certain ways to do things and steps to success that involve much more than daydreaming about the Great American Novel that I’m going to write.

So, I think that is one of the reasons writers feel a bit wary when outside-folks ask uninformed questions. But, really, that’s not a good response. I mean, I have no clue what my friends day-to-day lives are like in big-time consulting firms. Heck, I can’t even understand what my dad does!

But, we can still commiserate, right? About the funny questions? The ones where you inwardly shake your head and are just like “Bless their little hearts!” (Which is Southern for, “what a simple-minded question”–kidding! kidding!)

Well, here are a few of my favorite. (And for anyone that lives with a writer in their midst, I hope these help enlighten.)

 

1. So, if your agent is looking for a publisher, huh? And that publisher is in Texas? Like in Austin?

My in-my-head response: Wait, what? No, no Texas publisher. Do you know of a Texas publisher? I think you are very confused about what is going on, my friend. My agent is subbing to Random House, Simon & Schuster, Penguin…the works, yanno, like real life, you’ve-heard-of-them-before publishers.  This isn’t some weird mini version of dress up or a tea party with plastic crumpets. My agent is in NYC as are most (but definitely not all) publishing houses.

 

2. So, your agent is just like a middleman, huh? That’s annoying. Everywhere has a middleman these days. I bet when you graduate law school you’ll be happy because you can be your own agent.

My in-my-head response: Wait, what? No! I never, ever, never, ever would want to be my own agent! Even if I were an agent I wouldn’t be my own agent! An agent does more than draw up a contract. They manage your career. They know where your project should go. They know what terms are boilerplate and what to fight for. Your agent may be your one constant throughout your career. And can keep up the good relations between you, your editor, and your house. My agent reps awesome people like Ingrid Law and worked with Christopher Paolini. I should only be so lucky to have him!

 

3. You act excited that you got an agent, but don’t you just hire one? And, oh yeah, how much do you pay your agent?

My in-my-head response: Nothing! I pay my agent nothing! That is the awesomeness that is an agent. Someone believed in my project enough to dedicate free labor to it because he believes he can sell it. He gets paid if I get paid. That’s it. I’m excited because I was plucked from the horridness that slush and deposited onto the client list of a super awesome agent. I went through lots and lots and lots to get there. You don’t just hire an agent. Even though he *technically* works for me. The agents choose who to take on and it is a selective process. One to which pages and pages of writerly angst have been dedicated. Signing with a reputable agent is a major milestone in most writers lives.

4. So can I go buy your book? [says person that knows I just signed with Agent Man fairly recently]

My in-my-head response: Even if he sold my book the day I signed, the answer would still be no. Not in the next month. Not in the next year. At this point, we’re looking at 2010 at the earliest! Some editors have already started buying for 2011 lists. There is editing and more editing. Talented folks have to come up with cover art. There is marketing to plan. There is copyediting. And ARCs to give out. And blurbs to get. So much to do! Goodness, I’d have a heart attack if it happened as fast as people think it does.

 

5. My dad wrote a book. It’s on Amazon. Will yours be on, like, shelves? Or how much do you pay to get it published?

My in-my-head response: Again, nothing. In fact, a book deal (garnered by a reputable agent) makes you money. Otherwise agents would not be very pumped about this biz. And yes, all the places that my work is being subbed to have bookstore distribution. It would be on shelves and in real life. Very cool.

 

6. I edit a lot of work. I was my school’s newspaper editor. I could be your editor!

My in-my-head response: That’s really sweet. But, editors are actually the people at the publishing houses that acquire the books. They do the professional editing. Before that, my fabulous critique partner edits. Nate does some editing. And my agent helps in the editing process as well.

 

7. Cool, can you hook me up with your agent?

My in-my-head response: Oh dear. Awkward, awkward, awkward. When I have a book sale under my belt, I’m sure I’ll feel a bit more comfortable doing this for people whose projects I believe in. I’d have to be really really familiar with someone’s work and would probably want to be the one to bring it up. Although who knows? I’m just not at that point yet. The only person’s work that I know well enough is my critique partner and she already has a fabulous agent of her own.

The Writing Olympics

The Olympics start in a couple days and I got to thinking: Wouldn’t it be cool if we had Olympics for writers?

I mean, especially if it was for amateurs only like back in the day.

What would The Writing Olympics be like?

1. You think the Opening ceremony is long now? At The Writing Olympics the ceremony would go on and on and on and the announcers would use words like ”gallant,” “laudable,” and “superheroic” to describe the events to come.

2. Instead of gold medals, winners would earn six-figure publishing contracts. Silver medalists would win five-figure deals and bronze medal winners would walk away with a “nice” four-figure advance.

3. The national anthem? No way. The gold medal writers would hear their manuscript’s playlist booming over the loudspeakers as they solemnly held their hands over their hearts and sipped a latte.

4. The events? Well, the Nanowrimo word wars would certainly make a primetime appearance. The other events may be less riveting to watch. Some of the highlights would be:

-Who can have the most friends on MySpace, Live Journal, and Twitter combined?

-Battle of the Forum mods

-Most creative means of procrastination

-A gladiator-style melee to determine the next J.K. Rowling

 

Ok, I’m thinking The Writing Olympics may not be a breakout success. I guess I’ll have to revert to the Beer ones.

Have any ideas on what should be in The Writing Olympics??

 

To win advance copies of The Gargoyle follow this link to participate in the AW blog scavenger hunt! 

 

Status:  Did some writing, but mainly am getting ready to leave for Texas tomorrow. I got a few more requests for SCOUT. Keep your fingers crossed for me, please!!

Thursday Pics: Countdown to Austin

I can’t believe I’m moving to Texas SO SOON! I’ve boxed up most of my belongings. I’ve thrown away a couple dressers. I’m selling things on craigslist. I’m almost good to go. My official move-in date at my new apartment is August 11th, but I’ll be heading down to Texas a little earlier than that. But I’m moving out of my Philadelphia apartment next weekend, so that I can come to DC to spend some time with Nate.

Nate and I won’t see each other for a month and a half! That’s by far the most time we’ve had apart in three years and I am not happy about it. Nate will be moving down September 15.

The closer the move gets, the happier I am with my decision to attend law school at the University of Texas. I was deciding between UT, Cornell, and Vanderbilt. I’m pretty sure I wouldn’t have been all that happy at Cornell. Vandy would have been fun, but I’m really excited about living in Austin and getting the big football school experience, since I went to Penn for undergrad. I can’t believe I’m going to be a lawyer. Weird.

Anyway, here are some pictures of Austin and UT and Nate and I not looking as excited to be Longhorns as we are on the inside.

 

     

 

 

 

Status: Tomorrow, I’m leaving for Cincinnati with Nate and his family for their family reunion. So last night I went to the Bethesda library to stock up on books for the trip. I got The Boyfriend List by E. Lockhart, Sloppy Firsts by Megan McCafferty, and Betrayed by P.C. and Kristin Cast. (Yes, more YA. I write YA, I read YA–I can’t help loving it, so no apologies here.) Then, Nate took me to the bookstore and, though we were just going to look, he surprised me by buying Marked by P.C. and Kristin Cast and Eclipse by Stephenie Meyer. Now, there is only one copy of Eclipse between the two of us, so watch out!

Today, I’ve got to buckle down on SCOUT, so I can sent it out sometime next week or the following Monday by snail mail. Also, I’m feeling like I have ants in my pants. I started thinking about a submission I have out to an independent press that I love, love, love and I was just thinking how much I wanted an acceptance. Plus, I’m still waiting to hear from agents. How much can a girl take?

Thursday Pic: I’m a Graduate!

A couple weeks ago I graduated from the University of Pennsylvania! Congratulations to the rest of the Class of 2008! It’s easy to forget what a huge accomplishment graduating college is, but we should all be very proud. Go us!

Tomorrow, I’m off to visit my new home (come this August), Austin, Texas where I will be starting law school at UT in the fall.

The boyfriend is also moving down to Austin and this will be his first time seeing the city in which he’ll be living for at least the next three years. Hope he likes it!

Hook ‘em horns!

Status: Wow, I must have done something good because the muse decided to kick in full force last night! I got so many plot points out for the new WIP; It was fantastic. I think this project could be Big! For now, let’s call the new WIP SCOUT because the main characters name is Scarlett Roberts, but she goes by Scout. Another tidbit: It is Young Adult urban fantasy set in Philadelphia. I have given myself a self-imposed, but not completely arbitrary first draft deadline of August 10. That is the day I am planning on moving down to Texas for good. That is a really tight deadline, know, but I want to get another novel out before I start law school at the end of August. I will be waaaaaaaaaay too busy for anything but some light revising at first.